Best Sump Pump: A Comprehensive Guide for Buyers

WAYNE WAPC250 1/4 HP Automatic ON/OFF Water Removal Pool Cover Pump

Flooding is one of the most common problems in the house, which is being dreaded by many because it can be costly. It can damage your home and your appliances, which is why many have been proactive in their approach in order to lessen the possibility of water damage, especially in the basement. With this, there is no wonder why many choose to invest in a high-quality sump pump.

In case you have been living in a cave, sump pumps are simply pumps that will help to clear water drainage. It will help in the removal of water that has accumulated, making the process quicker and easier compared to removing it manually. It is available in different brands and models, but this should never be an excuse for you to decide in haste. At the end of the day, it is important to carefully evaluate the choices before you make any final decision.

What is the best sump pump that is available in the market today? If this is your question, keep on reading, and by the time that you are finished, you will find the answer that you have been looking for. We will provide you with insights on some of the most important factors to consider, as well as five of the best options that can be taken into account.

The 5 Best Sump Pump On The Market

Types of Sump Pump

Before anything else, it is important to consider the different types of sump pumps that are available in the marketplace. You should consider your specific needs or the intended applications in order to find the right one for you.

  • Pedestal Sump Pumps: This type of sump pump is meant to be used above the surface of the water and it is never meant to be submerged. One of its most important parts is the internal propeller, or what is technically known as an impeller and the one that is responsible for pumping water out of the area being cleaned. This is an excellent alternative for those who are looking for an affordable choice.
  • Submersible Sump Pumps: Between the two types of sump pumps, this is the one that can be asserted as being better. They are made in such a way that they will be able to operate effectively even when submerged underwater. They can deliver a wide array of benefits that cannot be found in pedestal sump pumps, such as better efficiency, performing with lesser noise, being easier to handle, longer lasting, and being hidden from the sump basin.

Choosing the Right Horsepower

In order to determine the power and performance of the sump pump, you have to take a look at its technical specifications, specifically its horsepower. You should select a model with higher horsepower if you want the sump pump to eject more water within a shorter period of time. Nonetheless, it is also important to note that if the horsepower is higher, it is more likely that the sump pump will also be more expensive.

Selecting the Right Switch

The switch will be one of the most important parts of the sump pump, which is why it should never be ignored. Generally speaking, the following are your choices:

  • Tethered Switch: Some of the most significant benefits of this switch include having a longer run time and longer rest time. However, one of the drawbacks is that a larger sump pit will be required.
  • Vertical Switch:This switch is preferred by many because it can operate even if the sump pit is narrow. However, one of the drawbacks is that it needs to run more frequently, and hence, the rest time is significantly shorter.
  • Electronic Switch: One of its benefits is that there are no moving parts, and hence, no component will be prone into being stuck. Nonetheless, if there are contaminants in your water, they can clog the switch and affect its performance.

Other Factors to Consider

Aside from those that have been mentioned above, make sure to also consider the following factors in your search for the perfect sump pump:

  • Materials: This will have an impact on the durability, performance, and price of the sump pump. Some of the most popular include cast iron and steel, which are known for being stronger. There are also options that are made from plastic or thermoplastic, which may be less durable, but ideal for those who are looking for cheap alternatives.
  • Reviews: If you are clueless with regards to which one to pick, it will also be good if you can read reviews from other people. Through their experiences, it will be easier to weigh the pros and cons of the options that you will be confronted with.
  • ​Mode of Operation: With a manual sump pump, you will need to have it manually turned on and off if there is a need to do so. On the other hand, in the case of an automatic sump pump, it will automatically turn on and off based on certain parameters, such as water pressure or level.
  • ​Warranty: If the manufacturer is confident about the quality of their product, they will not hesitate to offer a comprehensive warranty coverage. In most instances, the warranty will last for one year, which can give you peace of mind with regards to the functionality of the sump pump that you will buy.
  • Price: It is undeniable that many people would decide on the basis of the price of the sump pump. Nonetheless, it is important to keep in mind that such should be seen as an investment. Therefore, you must be willing to spend more if this is tantamount into being able to enjoy a product with superior quality and functionality.

Our Top Picks for the Best Sump Pump

1. Superior Pump 91250 ¼ HP Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump

Consistency and reliability – these are two of the things that make this model an option that is hard to match. It can deliver an astounding performance, which is proven with its 30-gallon per minute capacity. It also comes with a ¼ horsepower motor, which influences its performance.

The rugged design of this model is one more thing that should be commended. It is made from thermoplastic, which is a cheap material but does not fall short when it comes to durability. This means that even through the years, you can expect the sump pump to deliver the highest level of functionality.

Another element of design that should be highlighted about this product is its compact size. With its space-efficient design, it can easily fit in openings that can be as small as 6 inches.

Lastly, words of praises have been also expressed with regards to the quiet operation of this sump pump. Even if it comes with a powerful motor and has the ability to drain water quickly, it can perform without the need to make an annoying noise.

​Things We Liked:

  • Quiet performance
  • Rugged body
  • Compact design

​Things We Didn’t Like:

  • Warranty is limited
  • Prone to oil leaks

2. Wayne WAPC250 ¼ HP Automatic On/Off Water Removal Pool Cover Pump

Among other things, one of the most impressive features of this model is the iSwitch technology, which is also asserted as one of the reasons why it is believed to be user-friendly. With this technology, you do not have to manually switch on or off the pump. It will sense water on its own and will turn on and power off based on the water level detected.

Another thing that is worth highlighting about this model is the automatic freeze protection. This will prevent water inside the pump from freezing, even when subjected to a cold temperature. This will be beneficial in terms of making the pump longer lasting.

When it comes to durability, this is one option that can prove to be perfect. This is equipped with various features that will make it able to withstand long-term use, such as the strainer base, which will help to filter debris to avoid the problem of clogging.

Lastly, this sump pump is also well-loved by many users because of its thermoplastic construction, which is another reason why you can expect it to be durable. The latter can also resist corrosion to ensure its long-term functionality.

​Things We Liked:

  • Corrosion-resistant
  • Freeze protection
  • Automatic switch

​Things We Didn’t Like:

  • A bit expensive
  • Poor customer support

3. Zoeller M53 Mighty Mate Submersible Sump Pump

If there is one reason why you should choose this model, it would be the fact that it is the oldest manufacturer of sump pumps in the US. It has been around since 1939. Its many years of experience made it able to establish a reputation that is hard to match by any brand.

The durable construction of this sump pump is one of the many reasons why it stood out from the competition. All of the components of the pump are rust-resistant. It is also made from solid polypropylene, which is known for its ability to resist punctures.

If there is one thing that can be attributed for its powerful performance, it would be its dependable motor. It has a four-pole motor, which can operate at lesser revolutions compared to their two-pole counterparts.

The quality of the impeller is another feature that should be commended. It has a vortex-style impeller, which is known for its ability to allow solids up to ½ inch to easily pass through the screen, and hence, minimizing the possibility of clogging.

Lastly, it is also impressive as it has watertight construction, which will eliminate the possibility of leaking.

​Things We Liked:

  • Leak-free
  • Less prone to clogging
  • Powerful

​Things We Didn’t Like:

  • Poor quality float switch
  • A bit expensive

4. Wayne CDU980E ¾ HP Submersible Sump Pump

One of the most impressive features of this sump pump is its stainless steel body. This is a material that is better in terms of longevity as against thermoplastic. This may be a bit heavier, but it will all be worth it since you can be confident that it will be functional for an extended period of time.

When it comes to power, it cannot be denied that this is going to be an exceptional pick. It comes with a ¾ HP motor, which gives it the ability to pump water at a powerful rate. It is also a good thing that it is a submersible pump, making it useful for a wide array of applications.

If you are looking for a sump pump that is easy to install, this is one option that should be on the top of your list. Even on your own, you can complete the installation process and be confident that the system will be working as expected.

Lastly, we also liked this model because of the 5-year limited warranty that is offered by the manufacturer. This is way better than the warranty coverage of most of the sump pumps from the competition, which only have warranty of one year.

​Things We Liked:

  • Easy to install
  • Stainless steel construction
  • 5-year warranty

​Things We Didn’t Like:

  • A bit expensive
  • Prone to rust

5. Wayne EEAUP250 ¼ HP Water Removal Pump

With the abundance of the innovative features that you can find in this product, one of the most notable is the iSwitch technology. The latter is one of the reasons why it is excellent when it comes to ease of use. With this innovation, the water will automatically switch on if it is able to detect water at a certain level.

This pump comes with sealed thermoplastic construction, which makes it safe to say that this is going to be impressive when it comes to durability. Since the material is thermoplastic, you can be confident that it will be rust-free for life, unlike those that are made from steel. More so, since it is sealed, it will also be free from leaks.

A lot of users were also happy with its 3,000 gallons per hour flow rate, which can be attributed to its 1/4 HP motor.

When it comes to ease of use, you will have another good reason to pick this model. You do not have to watch over the unit as it operates. You can leave it unattended and be assured of the right outcomes.

​Things We Liked:

  • Easy to use
  • Rust-resistant
  • Powerful flow rate

​Things We Didn’t Like:

  • Poor quality attachment
  • Prone to clogging

Infographic-Best Sump Pump

Best Sump Pump Infographic

Best Sump Pump Infographic


In sum, buying the best sump pump is not an easy process. There are several things that should be taken into account and price alone will not be enough factor to consider. Do not make things any harder for you. With this, stick to the five choices that we have recommended above, and for sure, you will end up making a decision that you will not regret.